The plumber was great. He told us what to do, and once we did it, to call him back and he'd get everything up and running. Basically we had to rip up the floor around the toilet, lay down some plywood, and he'd come back and get the toilet on. Ken and I chatted back and forth, trying to decide if we should just replace the whole floor, or just the damaged area. And then we thought about renovating the whole bathroom.
Exhibit One: Our ugly bathroom (notice I didn't bother to tidy before taking the photo)
Our house was built in the early 80's, and this bathroom is a good example of ICK. It was functional, although I prefer more drawers than the cupboards. Don't you just love the lights? And if you look to the far right you'll see about a foot of totally wasted space under the counter.
We decided to go with a linen tower, which I LOVE. Lots of extra storage, which will come in handy when all the kids have to share a bathroom when they are older (because we are never moving.ever.again.)